Wednesday, April 27, 2011

List of questions to determine if an action is ethical or not:

- Does the action conflict with the ethics policy?
- Does the action conflict with the code of conduct?
- Is the action legal or illegal?
- Could the action cause prejudice or potential prejudice to the company or the employees?
- Does the action require authorisation?
- Who is responsible for the action?
- Does the action require dishonesty?
- What emotions are involved with taking action?
- Does the action require specific training?

Limiting Exposure to Fraud when Employing New Staff

If an organization is to prevent fraud successfully it must have effective policies that minimize the chance of hiring or promoting individuals with low levels of honesty, especially for position of trust.

Pro-active procedures should include the following, before appointing any employee:

• Conduct a background investigation on the individual who apply for employment or for promoting to a position of trust.
• Thoroughly checking a candidate’s education, employment history and personal references.



These above procedures are also known as staff vetting, which means that all applicants are screened thoroughly before employment is offered.
The following should be checked as part of the screening process:

• references,
• criminal records,
• civil records,
• disciplinary records,
• insolvency,
• other businesses,
• qualifications – CV audit,
• technical competence,
• psychometric testing

These preventive measures, however time consuming and costly, would assist them in appointing the correct candidate.

Motivating the Need for Fraud Prevention

Cost savings and increased profits - Annual company losses by means of fraud can be prevented by enforcing the right standards and procedures. If a company suffers losses due to crime, prices of goods and services are increased to make up for the losses, in other words, the consumer has to pay the losses. The other expense regarding crime within a company is detection and investigation costs, and implementing of control costs like computer systems, or clock cards. If fraud is decreased by means of internal controls, profits increase.

Reputational risk - In the case of Enron, it became public that the company was defrauded, and Enron then became a company with one of the worst reputations in the world. Having a good company reputation means that the public trusts the company and is willing to invest in such a company. If a company suffers from a negative reputation, shares will decrease, consumers will stop supporting the company, and other companies can choose to terminate contracts or friendships with such a company.



Positive work environment and staff morale - When fraud is discovered, negative feelings arise in a company. Management needs to make critical decisions about disciplining or firing employees, and relationships between all levels of employees are changed, mutual trust is affected. When there is no fraud losses, the company doesn’t suffer any losses, there is no reputational risk, and staff morale does not suffer.

Monday, October 25, 2010

Characteristics of a Good Report

• A well-written report “tells a story”. A report must answer the following questions: who, what, when, where, why, how and how much.

• Facts is stated accurately

• Explain the regulations and apply it to the facts.

• Report must stand alone

• List the interviews and documentation you reviewed in the report.

• Provide responsible authority the information they need to get a fair decision.

• A report must be complete

• Address all allegations and emerging allegations during the investigation.

• Explain how you addressed these allegations.

• Discuss all evidence

• Thoroughly discuss and analyze the rule and regulations pertaining to the investigations.


• A report must be clear and logical. A person that has no knowledge of the case must be able to understand how you reached your conclusion.

• Use direct and clear language.

• Present all information in a logical manner (from facts to conclusion)

• You must convince the reader that you r conclusion are supported by the facts you gathered.

• Make a clear distinction between facts, assumptions, conclusions and
opinions.

• Avoid emotional, judgmental or value-laden words.

• Use a simple, direct approach.

Common Report Writing Mistakes

• Completeness: Failing to have all its parts an support as expected in the report format

• Independence: Not enough information to help the reader understand it by oneself.

• Timeliness: Reports that are given in later than expected.


• Accountability: Failing to deliver according to specific disciplinary actions for subjects. Facts that are incorrectly used or in the inappropriate format and sentences.

• Forwarding the report: Failing to use the Post-Investigation checklist to conduct a quality review of the report before forwarding it to the authority.

Report Writing

• A report is a formal statement of the result of an investigation.

• In academic writing there are two main types of reports;
o Investigation report (e.g. case study)
o Evidence based report (e.g. evaluation report)

• You must know the purpose of the report.

• Is it a case study report for an ethnographic research report?

• Is it an investigation or an evaluation about something?

• Is it an assignment for your course?

• Must know who will be reading the report and why; because it will clarify the purpose of the report to you and to identify an appropriate form.

• Is it intended to shed light, and if so the findings from the data evidence is crucial.

• Is it reporting on something observed, and if so the findings will relate to conclusions and possibly recommendations.

• What is the report subject or focus, title or question?

• Describe your research in several sentences to define your focus.

• What are the main questions that define your research?

• Draft several working titles and choose the one which will help you keep to the point.

• In an observation report you have to make recommendations and check your focus with them.

• In an investigative report you need to know whether, your findings based on data analyses, what your aims or rationale are and whom your key authorities are.

• Make sure of what guidelines or information have been given for the report.

• Planning is crucial, experiment with the most logical order of presenting the information you have collected.


• There is 5 stages of a report:
o Introduction
o Methods
o Research
o Summary (abstract) and
o Discussion

• The 4 stages of writing a report:
o Outlining
o Drafting
o Revising and editing
o Presentation

• Make sure that your:
o Introduction still reflect on your findings
o Aims are rationale
o Literature review support your arguments
o Bibliography and references is up to date
o Methodology is used correctly
o Results in findings should be presented in a way that draws the readers attention
o Discussion includes conclusions and recommendations/ evaluations

• Structure of a report:
o Title – avoid overlong and snappy or newspaper style titles.
o Contents – useful for lengthy reports.
o Summary / abstract – usually written after initial draft on main report.
o Introduction – is the problem or issue that is the subject of the project.
o Main Body includes – Purpose, Literature review, Methodology / data collection, what you found out and discussion.
o Conclusions – what your conclusion is,
o Bibliographical references – List of material used in the report.
o Acknowledgements – mention people who helped you
o Appendixes – extra material which you referred to
o Glossary –
• Linguistic feature of report writing:
o Topic sentences
o Tense
o Cohesion
o Acronyms

• The main consideration for both style and language is clarity.

Visual Aids for Reports

Visual aids help to make a report more attractive and exciting to read. A visual aid helps to express the image that you want to create with the data. This can also enhance or clarify the explanation of the report. Different types of visual aids can be used for the type of you report image you want to create.
Visual aids help the reader understand the case. They are especially helpful when there are multiple witnesses, events or other complex relationships involved.

The visual aids that can be used to make a report more presentable are:

• Time flow diagrams: to show the chronological flow of events.
Interview memoranda constitute the bulk of the investigative report. Upon completion of the investigation, it is necessary for the examiner only to assemble the notes in order, prepare an index, list of exhibits and a synopsis in order to complete the paperwork. Clear and concise language is the hallmark of a good memorandum of interview. Avoid using the third person, that is, “the interviewer” instead of “I”. Also, don’t use stilted or pretentious wording.

• Matrix diagram: to illustrate the association of persons or things.
In addition to the facts of the case, fraud examiners should include several other items in the memorandum of interview that can help to make the visual aid more effective and complete.
Such as:
The witness’s name and contact information.
The investigator’s identity
Evidence provided, such as documents
A statement that the interview was voluntary
The date of the interview
The date the memorandum was prepared
How the interview was conducted (ie. In person or by phone)
If the interview was tape-recorded.

• Charts:
o Column chart: it is a good way to make data visual so that one can clearly see where values differ from one another.
o Line chart: In some cases you don’t just want a direct visual of data, but especially know where values have changed over a time period.
o Circle chart: can be used when you want to see which part each item makes out in total.


• Maps: can be used to illustrate the geographical position where certain events occurred. You can link a series of events and see what they all have in common or where a certain hot spot is.

• Building plans: can be used to illustrate place of events within a building. You can then have clarity of what is where or to see if the witnesses statement given is truthful and in accordance.

• Drawings/sketches: can be used to illustrate position of persons, items where crime took place. A simple drawing can be used to identify certain characteristics that can be useful for explaining the image you want people to understand.

• Video presentation: this can help the people to visualize the occurrences in the format that it happened. Videotape electronically carries both a picture and a sound track. Its features of sound, movement, vivid image, color, and variety hold an audience's attention the way film does. Videotape can be used to program an entire presentation, or to support a speaker's remarks by highlighting certain topics. By using this visual, it helps people to understand the situation with more ease.

• Photos: Actual pictures taken at the scene of the crime can help to put it all together. Photos will visualize what the data is saying and then it is easier to understand and to interpret for oneself.

• Posters: are prepared graphic devices that can be made of a variety of materials and media - photographs, diagrams, graphs, word messages, or a combination of these. Each poster should contain one message or theme. Words, charts, diagrams, and other symbols must be penned in a large enough size to be seen by everyone in the room.

• Organization chart: can be used to illustrate hierarchical relationships, such as department managers and employees within a company. You can organize all your data into headings, subheadings so that it can be easy understandable and neat. The audience will then be able to see the whole report clearly and understand how everything fits in where.